Why You Should Consider Rolling Equity When Selling Your Business

Selling a business often culminates years of hard work, dedication, and strategic planning. It marks a significant financial milestone, but how you structure the sale can have lasting implications on your financial health and future opportunities. One option that business owners frequently contemplate is maintaining a portion of equity in the business as part of the sale. This approach involves taking a portion of the sale proceeds in the form of equity in the acquiring company rather than all cash upfront. While it may not be ideal for every situation or seller, there are many reasons why rolling over equity should be carefully considered:

Tax Deferral Benefits

One of the main advantages of rolling over equity is the potential to defer immediate capital gains taxes. When you sell a business outright for cash, typically, you are liable for capital gains tax on the entire amount. However, by accepting equity in the acquiring company as part of the deal structure, you can defer these taxes until you eventually sell your equity stake.

This tax deferral strategy can be beneficial if you expect to be in a lower tax bracket in the future or if you are trying to minimize immediate taxes. Consultation with tax experts is crucial to understand your situation's specific tax implications and benefits.

Alignment of Interests

Rolling equity often aligns the interests of the seller with the buyer. When a portion of the sale proceeds is reinvested in the acquiring company’s equity, you become a shareholder in the new entity. This can motivate one to contribute to the success and growth of the combined entity, as your best interest is now tied to its performance.

Also, maintaining an equity stake can provide ongoing financial benefits if the buyer performs well and its stock value appreciates over time. This potential for future growth can sometimes outweigh the immediate cash alternative, depending on your financial goals and risk tolerance. This future potential is often referred to as “The second bite of the apple.”

Continued Involvement and Influence

For business owners who are passionate about their industry or sector, rolling equity can offer them the opportunity to remain involved in the business they built and with the employees they’ve hired. Depending on the terms of the transaction, you may have a seat on the board of directors, advisory roles, or other forms of influence over strategic decisions.

This continued involvement can be personally fulfilling and allow you to leverage your expertise and industry knowledge for the benefit of the acquiring company. It also provides a smoother transition period, ensuring your legacy and vision are preserved and integrated into the new organization.

Your Business, Our Expertise – A Winning Combination.

Diversification and Risk Management

Diversifying your investment portfolio is a fundamental principle of sound financial planning. By rolling over equity into a larger, diversified entity, you can reduce the concentration risk that comes from holding a large portion of your wealth in a single asset—the cash proceeds from selling your business.

While equity investments carry their own risks, spreading your wealth across different asset classes can potentially mitigate overall risk and improve your financial resilience. This diversification strategy is especially valuable for business owners who have invested heavily in their company and seek to balance their post-sale portfolio.

Preservation of Business Legacy

Many entrepreneurs are deeply attached to the legacy and reputation of the businesses they have built. Selling to an acquiring company that values and respects this legacy can be more appealing than a purely financial transaction. By rolling over equity, you can choose a buyer who is committed to preserving and building upon the foundations you have laid.

Maintaining a stake in the acquiring company allows you to influence its culture, values, and strategic direction, ensuring that your business’s legacy continues to thrive in the years to come. This sense of continuity and stewardship can be gratifying for business owners who are passionate about leaving a lasting impact.

Negotiating Power and Flexibility

From a negotiation standpoint, offering to roll over equity can strengthen your position at the bargaining table. It demonstrates your confidence in the future success of the combined entity and aligns your interests with those of the acquiring company. This alignment can lead to more favorable terms, such as a higher overall valuation or better post-sale incentives.

Furthermore, structuring the sale with a combination of cash and equity provides flexibility in managing your financial affairs. You can tailor the transaction to meet your liquidity needs while optimizing tax efficiency and long-term financial goals.

Deciding whether to roll over equity when selling your business is a complex decision that depends on various factors, including your financial objectives, tax considerations, and personal preferences. While cash offers immediate liquidity and certainty, rolling over equity provides potential tax advantages, alignment of interests, continued involvement, diversification benefits, preservation of legacy, and negotiating flexibility.

Before making a final decision, consulting with financial advisors, tax professionals, and legal experts who specialize in mergers and acquisitions is crucial. They can help you evaluate the pros and cons, navigate the complexities of the transaction, and ensure that your interests are protected throughout the process.

Ultimately, rolling equity can be a strategic choice that not only maximizes the financial outcome of the sale but also aligns with your broader goals for the future. By carefully weighing the benefits and considerations outlined above, you can make an informed decision that sets you on a path toward continued success and financial security post-sale.

Schedule a Call